It's always nice to have choices. And if you like traditional leather saddles, as I do, then you may be glad to know there are some new choices available. Italian saddle maker Selle Italia (whose name literally means "Italian Saddle") has just re-introduced a line of traditional leather saddles to help mark their 120th anniversary. Although I haven't seen any mention of "Eroica" in the news and press releases, the growing popularity of those vintage-bike events make this introduction seem totally natural.
The company's new Heritage leather saddle line also bears a slightly different name - Sella Italia (notice that it's "Sella" with an "a" not "e" at the end). There are three models available in this new line: the Storica racing saddle, which is long and narrow -- something akin to a Brooks Swift; the Epoca, which is a little wider and shorter for all-day comfort with a more upright position; and the Mitica, which is somewhere in-between for long rides at a more aggressive pace. All three saddles feature bag loops at the back, which is a nice practical touch.
One thing I found interesting in this bit of news is that the saddle maker still had many of the old leather presses from the days before the company shifted its attention to molded plastic saddles (like that '80s-defining classic, the Selle Italia Turbo), and those tools have been "pressed" back into service for this new throwback line.
However these new models are not just a simple reproduction of the company's old leather saddles from the '50s. The construction of these incorporates some new technology as well, which could improve the durability. Instead of a single layer of leather, Sella Italia is using a 3-layer sandwich construction: a two layers of leather with a mesh fabric bonded in-between. The leather is fixed to the frame using special bi-metal compression rivets that don't require hammering. The company says this construction will prevent sagging or damage from over-tensioning, increasing the life of the saddle.
In addition to the new saddles, there are also leather grips and small leather saddlebags. The bags look nice, but the small size of the ones I've seen mean they are probably not suitable for carrying much more than a spare tube and some compact tools.
The price of the saddles hasn't yet been released, but expect them to be a premium - probably $150 or more.
On a somewhat different but related note, I just saw a press release that Selle Italia has also taken over another major Italian saddle maker, Selle San Marco (their Concor model was another one that was very popular on racing bikes in the '80s). And to clear up some possible (likely) confusion, let me point out that neither of these is the same Italian saddle maker that currently owns Brooks saddles. That one is Selle Royal. In case there are still some lingering questions, there is yet another Selle out there -- Selle Anatomica - which despite the Italian-sounding name, is an American company making leather saddles that are known for their slotted-top design. Got it?
Wednesday, June 29, 2016
Monday, June 27, 2016
The Coolest Bike Accessory Of 932 A.D.
Remember this?
"You're using coconuts! You've got two empty halves of coconut and you're banging' 'em together!"
Well, now a company called Trotify brings us the coolest bike accessory of 932 A.D.
Mount this little tire-driven wooden contraption over your front wheel (it mounts to the front brake bolt) and you too can sound like a trotting horse, or one of King Arthur's knights.
The company's website has a couple of videos of the product in action. Here's one:
"Where'd you get the coconuts?"
"We found them."
"Found them? In Mercia? The coconut's tropical! This is a temperate zone."
"The swallow may fly south with the sun or the house martin or the plover may seek warmer climes in winter yet these are not strangers to our land."
"Are you suggesting coconuts migrate?"
Even if you're not so intent on sounding like a trotting horse, it looks like a fun little project anyhow. I'm thinking my kids might enjoy one.
Trotify was crowdfunded and the first units distributed to their backers last year, but the makers are now setting up for regular distribution. Anyone interested in the gadget should visit the site to be notified when the next batch is ready for purchase.
"You're using coconuts! You've got two empty halves of coconut and you're banging' 'em together!"
Well, now a company called Trotify brings us the coolest bike accessory of 932 A.D.
Mount this little tire-driven wooden contraption over your front wheel (it mounts to the front brake bolt) and you too can sound like a trotting horse, or one of King Arthur's knights.
The company's website has a couple of videos of the product in action. Here's one:
"Where'd you get the coconuts?"
"We found them."
"Found them? In Mercia? The coconut's tropical! This is a temperate zone."
"The swallow may fly south with the sun or the house martin or the plover may seek warmer climes in winter yet these are not strangers to our land."
"Are you suggesting coconuts migrate?"
Even if you're not so intent on sounding like a trotting horse, it looks like a fun little project anyhow. I'm thinking my kids might enjoy one.
Trotify was crowdfunded and the first units distributed to their backers last year, but the makers are now setting up for regular distribution. Anyone interested in the gadget should visit the site to be notified when the next batch is ready for purchase.
Sunday, June 26, 2016
Nothing Sounds Like "Heat" More Than the Drone of Cicadas
A few weeks ago, the 17-year cicadas emerged and the sound of their rattling filled the air, but nowhere was their sound more overwhelming than in our local bicycling mecca, the Cuyahoga Valley. The cicadas are still going, but now their drone is more of a death rattle. Out for a ride through the valley today, one could see them lethargically flitting from one tree to another, and often literally dropping dead to the ground. In some places, there were so many dead ones on the road that the unavoidable sound of their little bodies crunching under the tires was competition for the sound of the live ones still in the trees.
Yeah - that's kind of gross, but true nevertheless.
Having spent two recent weeks in London and Paris, where the temperature never rose above 65 degrees (American) the whole time we were there, it was a bit of a shock to the system to come home and find the temperatures up around 90. Somehow, the rattle of the cicadas makes it seem even hotter.
Feeling in kind of a vintage mood, I took my old 1980 Mercian Strada Speciale for the ride.
There's a nice long and twisty descent into the valley from Akron. I live in a part of the city known as Highland Square, which gets its name for a reason. It isn't the highest elevation in the city, but it's probably in the top three. Most of my rides start with a nice descent, and end with a breath-stealing climb. The hill on Portage Path has a pretty challenging S-curve in it, and combined with the grade, a skilled cyclist can get some serious speed going down. In fact, it's one of those rare hills where a cyclist can actually get down the hill faster than a car.
Today, going through the S-curve, I caught up with a car ahead of me -- a guy in a 7-series BMW. I had to grab some brake to stay off his bumper, and a touch of brake squeal alerted him to my presence. As the road straightened, he picked up the pace, and I just tucked into his draft. I'm guessing this guy must have seen Breaking Away a couple of times, because the next thing I see, he puts his hand out the window and extends all five fingers as if to signal "50 mph" like the driver in the Cinzano truck. At the bottom of the hill, he confirmed the speed, and sounded pretty impressed. I didn't tell him that if not for the fact that there were cars in the oncoming lane, I probably would have just passed him.
Once in the valley, I sought the shadier routes, and took a little trip around historic Hale Farm and Village and paused for a bit at the old covered bridge on Ira Road. I stopped to snap a picture, then found that the wild raspberries are ripening.
After looping around the Village of Peninsula, in the heart of the national park, I headed back toward home, but made sure to stop at Szlay's produce market for nice snack. (The raspberries were good, but not very filling). With a nice selection of fruit, I picked a big fat plumb. I can't eat plumbs without thinking of poet William Carlos Williams:
Don't ask me to explain it. I'm an English teacher, but I'm off duty. But it seems a good contrast with the heat.
While I was stopped for my snack, another rider noticed the vintage Mercian and came over to get a closer look. He was well able to appreciate the bike's 531 frame and original paint. I told him about my recent visit to the company's workshop and how I got to see some of the bikes being built and painted. That was a fine diversion.
After continuing through the valley, where the road skirts alongside the Cuyahoga River, I got back to the climb back up to the city. I love the look of the Mercian's old drilled-out Sugino crank, but times like this I wish I could put something smaller than a 42-tooth chainring on it. But you know what they say: Tough climbs keep you young. Okay, nobody actually says that, but they should.
Wherever you are, I hope you're enjoying the weather.
Yeah - that's kind of gross, but true nevertheless.
Having spent two recent weeks in London and Paris, where the temperature never rose above 65 degrees (American) the whole time we were there, it was a bit of a shock to the system to come home and find the temperatures up around 90. Somehow, the rattle of the cicadas makes it seem even hotter.
Feeling in kind of a vintage mood, I took my old 1980 Mercian Strada Speciale for the ride.
There's a nice long and twisty descent into the valley from Akron. I live in a part of the city known as Highland Square, which gets its name for a reason. It isn't the highest elevation in the city, but it's probably in the top three. Most of my rides start with a nice descent, and end with a breath-stealing climb. The hill on Portage Path has a pretty challenging S-curve in it, and combined with the grade, a skilled cyclist can get some serious speed going down. In fact, it's one of those rare hills where a cyclist can actually get down the hill faster than a car.
Today, going through the S-curve, I caught up with a car ahead of me -- a guy in a 7-series BMW. I had to grab some brake to stay off his bumper, and a touch of brake squeal alerted him to my presence. As the road straightened, he picked up the pace, and I just tucked into his draft. I'm guessing this guy must have seen Breaking Away a couple of times, because the next thing I see, he puts his hand out the window and extends all five fingers as if to signal "50 mph" like the driver in the Cinzano truck. At the bottom of the hill, he confirmed the speed, and sounded pretty impressed. I didn't tell him that if not for the fact that there were cars in the oncoming lane, I probably would have just passed him.
Once in the valley, I sought the shadier routes, and took a little trip around historic Hale Farm and Village and paused for a bit at the old covered bridge on Ira Road. I stopped to snap a picture, then found that the wild raspberries are ripening.
Delicious. But watch those prickers. |
I have eaten
the plumbs
that were in
the icebox
and which
you were probably
saving
for breakfast
Forgive me
they were delicious
so sweet
and so cold
While I was stopped for my snack, another rider noticed the vintage Mercian and came over to get a closer look. He was well able to appreciate the bike's 531 frame and original paint. I told him about my recent visit to the company's workshop and how I got to see some of the bikes being built and painted. That was a fine diversion.
After continuing through the valley, where the road skirts alongside the Cuyahoga River, I got back to the climb back up to the city. I love the look of the Mercian's old drilled-out Sugino crank, but times like this I wish I could put something smaller than a 42-tooth chainring on it. But you know what they say: Tough climbs keep you young. Okay, nobody actually says that, but they should.
Wherever you are, I hope you're enjoying the weather.
Wednesday, June 22, 2016
A Visit To Mercian Cycles
People may or may not have noticed a lack of posts to the blog for the last couple of weeks. I generally don't like to announce to the world at large when I'm out of town (Hey everyone on the internet, we'll be gone for two weeks on vacation - would somebody be kind enough to pop in to water our plants? The key's in one of those fake plastic "rocks" in the garden. Thanks!) but now that I'm back in the world of reliable WiFi, I don't mind revealing that I was gone on a pretty terrific family trip to London and Paris. It was an awesome experience, but now we're home.
As long as I was in England, I thought it would be a great opportunity to visit the folks at Mercian Cycles to see the shop and meet some of the folks who made some of my own bikes. So I boarded a train in London and rode about an hour-and-a-half north to Derby, where I was met at the station by the lovely Jane Mosely, co-owner of Mercian along with her husband Grant.
Before heading over to the shop, Jane took me to the recently opened Derby Velodrome - an impressive, modern facility that houses not only a state-of-the-art indoor track, but also a fitness center, and a concert venue. While we were there, we got to see a couple members of the British Women's Team warming up on a tandem.
Our next stop was the Mercian workshop, which sits in an unassuming little garage-like building in an industrial park, about a mile away from the retail store.
Stepping inside is almost like traveling back in time. I doubt that the workshop looks much different today than it would have about 50 years ago when they first moved the framebuilding operations into this building. Inside, I got to meet two of the Mercian builders - John, and John. Senior builder, Tony, was on vacation.
The younger John showed me the brazing on a Mercian fork. The open hearth brazing method is something the company is well-known for, and Mercian is one of the few builders that still use it.
Next I got to see the paint shop, where Rob and Phil were working their magic.
A special treat was next, as I got an insider's look at something I'm sure few people get to see - the design boards for a new collaboration between Mercian and famous fashion designer Paul Smith. Unfortunately, I cannot show the newest design, since it hasn't yet been released by Paul Smith, but I think I'm safe showing the boards from a couple of previous collaborations.
After the workshop, Jane drove me over to the retail store, where Grant and Carl were preparing some bikes to take to Eroica Brittania that upcoming weekend. Mercian would have a stand set up at the event.
Visiting the shop was a great experience, and I have to heartily thank Grant and Jane for their hospitality, and all the guys at the shop for taking time out to chat. It was a real pleasure!
The scene from outside the Derby rail station. |
Before heading over to the shop, Jane took me to the recently opened Derby Velodrome - an impressive, modern facility that houses not only a state-of-the-art indoor track, but also a fitness center, and a concert venue. While we were there, we got to see a couple members of the British Women's Team warming up on a tandem.
Our next stop was the Mercian workshop, which sits in an unassuming little garage-like building in an industrial park, about a mile away from the retail store.
Stepping inside is almost like traveling back in time. I doubt that the workshop looks much different today than it would have about 50 years ago when they first moved the framebuilding operations into this building. Inside, I got to meet two of the Mercian builders - John, and John. Senior builder, Tony, was on vacation.
There's John, working on a Vincitore bottom bracket. |
John shows me some of his work, explaining how the extra-long tangs are welded onto the shell, then filed seamlessly. That bottom bracket shell is a cool but dangerous-looking piece. |
The younger John showed me the brazing on a Mercian fork. The open hearth brazing method is something the company is well-known for, and Mercian is one of the few builders that still use it.
Next I got to see the paint shop, where Rob and Phil were working their magic.
Phil masks off the head tube lugs on a Vincitore model. |
Phil adds some lug lining to finish off a new fork. |
There's the color board, along with an old advertising sign from the '50s. |
Some of Rob's work - he mixes most of the colors himself. |
Seeing this set of boards, from a 2007 collaboration, I immediately spotted something familiar. Among the sketches and color samples were some photos of a bike that helped inspire Smith's design. That green and white frame shown was my own bike, built for me in 2003, and afterwards photographed for the company's website before shipping. That was very cool to see. |
Love the red, black, and gold scheme on this King of Mercia touring frame. |
Orange pearl and silver Vincitore track bike. |
I spotted this Eroica-ready bike (well, maybe everything except the dual-pivot brakes) out on the showroom floor. The color combination was truly eye-catching. |
These outline-only downtube decals were a cool touch I'd never seen before. |
Some new frames ready for purchase. |
Here's a limited edition path racer in the shop window. The bike uses vintage lugs from the '60s, and there are only enough of them for 10 classic-styled bikes. |
I spotted this cool poster hanging in the shop, but forgot to ask about how old it is. They ought to look into getting them reproduced. |
Grant, Jane, and me in front of the Mercian shop. (Thanks go to Carl for snapping the picture.) |
Friday, June 17, 2016
Classic Rendezvous Weekend Reports
There haven't been any Retrogrouch updates for at least a week or more - Sorry. Internet access has been spotty. More on that later.
In the meantime, I can report that the Classic Rendezvous group had a big vintage bike weekend recently in Greensboro, North Carolina. It's one of those events that any fan of vintage and classic bikes really must get to some time, though there hasn't been one for a couple years. I didn't get to go this year either, but it's nothing to feel too bad about. When there's more time, and better internet, I'll post all about that.
Until then, if you're looking for something new to read, here are a couple of reports from the CR weekend that might interest you - from somewhat newer blogs that I've been enjoying lately.
One report comes from Scott Calhoun at The Beautiful Bicycle.
Scott drove all the way from Tucson, Arizona to get to the event in North Carolina. His report was a nice read.
Also, there are several of articles about the Classic Rendezvous weekend from Brian Ignatin and Matthew Butterman of the Handbuilt Bicycle Guide.
CR weekend includes a vintage show with winners in various categories, and a full list of winners is on the HBG. Also, there were guest speakers for the event, including framebuilders Brian Chapman, Peter Johnson, and Dave Moulton, who gave different perspectives from different eras in bicycle building.
Another report people should definitely check out comes from Dave Moulton himself, whose blog is always worth a read.
Hopefully those will keep you busy until I can get back to more regular posts.
Cheers.
In the meantime, I can report that the Classic Rendezvous group had a big vintage bike weekend recently in Greensboro, North Carolina. It's one of those events that any fan of vintage and classic bikes really must get to some time, though there hasn't been one for a couple years. I didn't get to go this year either, but it's nothing to feel too bad about. When there's more time, and better internet, I'll post all about that.
Until then, if you're looking for something new to read, here are a couple of reports from the CR weekend that might interest you - from somewhat newer blogs that I've been enjoying lately.
One report comes from Scott Calhoun at The Beautiful Bicycle.
Scott drove all the way from Tucson, Arizona to get to the event in North Carolina. His report was a nice read.
Also, there are several of articles about the Classic Rendezvous weekend from Brian Ignatin and Matthew Butterman of the Handbuilt Bicycle Guide.
CR weekend includes a vintage show with winners in various categories, and a full list of winners is on the HBG. Also, there were guest speakers for the event, including framebuilders Brian Chapman, Peter Johnson, and Dave Moulton, who gave different perspectives from different eras in bicycle building.
Another report people should definitely check out comes from Dave Moulton himself, whose blog is always worth a read.
Hopefully those will keep you busy until I can get back to more regular posts.
Cheers.
Tuesday, June 7, 2016
Jocelyn Lovell - Canadian Cycling Hero: 1950 - 2016
Though a lot of cycling fans in the U.S. might not be familiar with the name, bike racer Jocelyn Lovell was as big of a hero in Canada as somebody like Greg LeMond here in the states. Lovell was a dominant force in Canadian cycling on both the track and road, and helped reinvigorate the sport in his country in much the way LeMond did in the U.S.
Jocelyn Lovell was born in England, but moved with his family to Canada at the age of four. He started bicycle racing when he was just 13, and competed in his first of three Olympics games in Mexico, 1968. He would have been only 18 years old and finished an impressive 6th on the track in the kilometer.
During his racing career, he won more than 35 national titles, competed in the 1968, 1972 and 1976 Olympics, and won numerous medals in the Commonwealth Games (including 4 golds), Pan American Games (2 golds), and World Championships (silver). In some of those performances, he set records that would stand for decades.
In 1983, while out for a training ride, Lovell was tragically hit and dragged by a dump truck. The resulting spinal cord injury left him a quadriplegic for the rest of his life.
Though the terrible incident ended Lovell's racing career, he was inducted into the Canadian Sports Hall of Fame in 1985. Just last year, he was among the first inductees into the new Canadian Cycling Hall of Fame.
Lovell would become a major advocate for spinal cord research in his life, but reportedly continued to suffer from health effects and complications from his life-changing accident. He died last week, June 3rd, with his second wife, Neil, at his bedside.
What a terrible loss. Jocelyn Lovell, Rest in Peace.
(photo from Toronto Star Archives) |
Lovell on the track, in his familiar national colors. |
Lovell on a bike built for him by Giuseppe Marinoni, who built a number of bikes for the Canadian racer. The two were reunited in the recent documentary about Marinoni, The Fire in the Frame. |
In 1983, while out for a training ride, Lovell was tragically hit and dragged by a dump truck. The resulting spinal cord injury left him a quadriplegic for the rest of his life.
Lovell with his first wife, speed skater Sylvia Burke, shortly after the tragic accident in 1983. (photo from the Toronto Star Archives) |
Lovell would become a major advocate for spinal cord research in his life, but reportedly continued to suffer from health effects and complications from his life-changing accident. He died last week, June 3rd, with his second wife, Neil, at his bedside.
What a terrible loss. Jocelyn Lovell, Rest in Peace.
Friday, June 3, 2016
It's Officially Summer
I know the Summer Solstice doesn't happen until June 20, but for me and the Retro-Kids, today is the official beginning of Summer. It's their first day of Summer break, we got to go out for a bike ride and picnic, and it's opening day for the little fruit market in the Cuyahoga Valley.
As far as the Retro-kids and I are concerned, Solstice or not, Summer has officially begun.
Our weather today has been perfect. A little hot in the sun, but a perfect day to be outside. We loaded up all the bikes and drove down to the CV National Park to ride the Ohio & Erie Canal Towpath.
"Move along little guy." |
Stopping for a rest at one of the old canal locks. |
As far as the Retro-kids and I are concerned, Solstice or not, Summer has officially begun.
Wednesday, June 1, 2016
GPs Thoughts on Disc Brakes
I saw this post on the Rivendell Blug not too long ago about disc brakes vs. rim brakes. Needless to say, Grant Petersen says a lot of the same things I do about disc brakes, but with his years of experience in the business, he still has a way of saying them with a certain authority that I simply don't have.
If I could summarize Petersen's view on disc brakes, it is that there's nothing exactly wrong with them, but they aren't the vast and remarkable improvement over good rim brakes that the industry has been pushing for the last few years. In other words, they don't make bikes with rim brakes obsolete, and shouldn't.
Petersen points out some of the benefits of disc brakes -- notably the fact that they are less affected by mud and water, and that they don't heat up rims to the point of tire blowout on scary-fast descents. Then again, for the majority of cyclists and conditions, those benefits are over-sold. And on the down-side, as he adds, the leverage of a disc brake concentrates a lot of force near the hub, putting a lot more stress on seat-stays, and on fork blades far from the crown. As a result, frames need to be beefed up in those areas, which can affect compliance and comfort. He also mentions how those braking forces concentrated out at the frame ends have been enough to overwhelm quick releases and even "lawyer tabs" on front forks, necessitating the move to through-axles. To wit, he asks the question, "Which is better -- a mechanical system that localizes stress on a small area, then bullies it into submission with bulk and beef, or one that disperses stress and spreads it out?"
He goes on to say, "Disc brakes are fine, but if the bike could speak for itself, it might request a rim brake. . . The fact is, rim brakes are getting pounded these days, but it's a kind of artificial pounding by fashion and commerce."
I would have to agree with that. I mean, if I were looking at a new bike on the showroom floor and the bike I wanted came with disc brakes, I certainly wouldn't reject it for that reason. But at the same time, I wouldn't be drawn to a particular bike because it had discs. And if there were another bike basically the same but with rim brakes, and selling for a lower price, I'd probably choose to save the money.
But there's another point to be made that resonates with me. And that is regarding the simplicity of a traditional rim brake. Everything is out in the open, easy to see and easy to maintain, while potential problems are easy to diagnose and solve. Some would likely point out that once a modern hydraulic disc brake system is set up properly, it needs little maintenance. To which I would respond that getting it set up properly is a lot more likely to be something that requires an experienced mechanic, and if something actually goes wrong (and things do, indeed, go wrong - even on the best of systems) it can be a lot harder to diagnose or solve. This is something I wrote about last year when a bike reviewer for BikeRadar had a pretty scary disc brake failure on a test ride. In that case, the brake components were sent back to Shimano for inspection, but ultimately, even they couldn't adequately explain how or why the failure occurred.
Petersen describes it like this: "Ultimately, you can expect the bicycle of the immediate future to become more of a high tech black box, with cables being replaced by hydraulics, and the visible levers and pulleys and other simple machines that combine into bicycle magic being hidden or replaced by electronics. The bicycle of the future will, absolutely, be shrouded in mystery and sold on reputation and faith, like a Samsung flat-screen TV."
He continues, "There's a tendency to trust mechanisms you can't see more than those you can, because when you see how something works, you see also the potential for failure. . . If you're mechanically adept you might be more attracted to something you can figure out and fix, but more people aren't that than are."
That really nails it for me, and it's something I've touched on again and again in this blog - whether it's electronic shifting, or disc brakes, or integrated/connected dashboards and other electronic gewgaws -- all that stuff makes the bike more of a "black box" (I like that description, so I'm using it) and takes it further from the simplicity that I value in a bicycle. Fly-by-wire electronic and hydraulic systems, for efficiency, comfort, and safety, all controlled by a state-of-the-art computer is fine for my car. But what makes a bicycle special is that it demonstrably doesn't need any of that to make it any better.
People do seem to like push-button/touch-screen convenience, which oddly enough seems so simple, but only because the far greater complexity is kept hidden, and only accessible by those who are specially trained and certified to look behind the plastic covers. That illusory simplicity is great when everything works as it should, but vanishes into the ether when something goes wrong. It's like a microwave oven. If something goes wrong, it ends up costing more to fix it than to just scrap it and buy a new one. Bikes and bike components shouldn't be that.
In the end of Petersen's blug post, he concludes by saying "Don't dis the rim brake. It's beautiful and it works, and today's rim brakes are better than ever."
Couldn't agree more.
If I could summarize Petersen's view on disc brakes, it is that there's nothing exactly wrong with them, but they aren't the vast and remarkable improvement over good rim brakes that the industry has been pushing for the last few years. In other words, they don't make bikes with rim brakes obsolete, and shouldn't.
Petersen points out some of the benefits of disc brakes -- notably the fact that they are less affected by mud and water, and that they don't heat up rims to the point of tire blowout on scary-fast descents. Then again, for the majority of cyclists and conditions, those benefits are over-sold. And on the down-side, as he adds, the leverage of a disc brake concentrates a lot of force near the hub, putting a lot more stress on seat-stays, and on fork blades far from the crown. As a result, frames need to be beefed up in those areas, which can affect compliance and comfort. He also mentions how those braking forces concentrated out at the frame ends have been enough to overwhelm quick releases and even "lawyer tabs" on front forks, necessitating the move to through-axles. To wit, he asks the question, "Which is better -- a mechanical system that localizes stress on a small area, then bullies it into submission with bulk and beef, or one that disperses stress and spreads it out?"
He goes on to say, "Disc brakes are fine, but if the bike could speak for itself, it might request a rim brake. . . The fact is, rim brakes are getting pounded these days, but it's a kind of artificial pounding by fashion and commerce."
I would have to agree with that. I mean, if I were looking at a new bike on the showroom floor and the bike I wanted came with disc brakes, I certainly wouldn't reject it for that reason. But at the same time, I wouldn't be drawn to a particular bike because it had discs. And if there were another bike basically the same but with rim brakes, and selling for a lower price, I'd probably choose to save the money.
But there's another point to be made that resonates with me. And that is regarding the simplicity of a traditional rim brake. Everything is out in the open, easy to see and easy to maintain, while potential problems are easy to diagnose and solve. Some would likely point out that once a modern hydraulic disc brake system is set up properly, it needs little maintenance. To which I would respond that getting it set up properly is a lot more likely to be something that requires an experienced mechanic, and if something actually goes wrong (and things do, indeed, go wrong - even on the best of systems) it can be a lot harder to diagnose or solve. This is something I wrote about last year when a bike reviewer for BikeRadar had a pretty scary disc brake failure on a test ride. In that case, the brake components were sent back to Shimano for inspection, but ultimately, even they couldn't adequately explain how or why the failure occurred.
Petersen describes it like this: "Ultimately, you can expect the bicycle of the immediate future to become more of a high tech black box, with cables being replaced by hydraulics, and the visible levers and pulleys and other simple machines that combine into bicycle magic being hidden or replaced by electronics. The bicycle of the future will, absolutely, be shrouded in mystery and sold on reputation and faith, like a Samsung flat-screen TV."
He continues, "There's a tendency to trust mechanisms you can't see more than those you can, because when you see how something works, you see also the potential for failure. . . If you're mechanically adept you might be more attracted to something you can figure out and fix, but more people aren't that than are."
That really nails it for me, and it's something I've touched on again and again in this blog - whether it's electronic shifting, or disc brakes, or integrated/connected dashboards and other electronic gewgaws -- all that stuff makes the bike more of a "black box" (I like that description, so I'm using it) and takes it further from the simplicity that I value in a bicycle. Fly-by-wire electronic and hydraulic systems, for efficiency, comfort, and safety, all controlled by a state-of-the-art computer is fine for my car. But what makes a bicycle special is that it demonstrably doesn't need any of that to make it any better.
People do seem to like push-button/touch-screen convenience, which oddly enough seems so simple, but only because the far greater complexity is kept hidden, and only accessible by those who are specially trained and certified to look behind the plastic covers. That illusory simplicity is great when everything works as it should, but vanishes into the ether when something goes wrong. It's like a microwave oven. If something goes wrong, it ends up costing more to fix it than to just scrap it and buy a new one. Bikes and bike components shouldn't be that.
In the end of Petersen's blug post, he concludes by saying "Don't dis the rim brake. It's beautiful and it works, and today's rim brakes are better than ever."
Couldn't agree more.