Monday, January 18, 2016

MLK: Need I Say More?

Sometimes a picture just says it all:


In honor of Martin Luther King Jr.

Friday, January 15, 2016

Here We Go Again: Freewheeling Cranks

Does anybody out there remember freewheeling cranks? Shimano introduced such a system in the late 1970s that they called Shimano FFS - for "Front Freewheel System." It had a freewheeling device built into the crank-bottom bracket interface. Combined with an extra stiff rear freewheel (Shimano called it a "friction freewheel") the system was designed so that the chainrings and chain would continue to move when coasting, thereby allowing the user to shift gears while coasting. The late great Sheldon Brown referred to it as "a solution in search of a problem."

Show of hands. Who's too dense to figure out shifting? WE ARE!

Apparently some beginning cyclists couldn't get the concept of shifting their new 10-speed derailleur bikes only while pedaling.

I can just picture them bringing their "defective" bikes back to the shop.

Customer: "There's something wrong with my new bike."
Bike Shop Manager: "Tell me about the problem."
Customer: "This thing won't shift when I'm coasting."
BSM: "That's not how it's supposed to work. You have to be pedaling when shifting."
Customer: "But why doesn't it work when I'm coasting?"
BSM: "That's not how it's designed. The chain has to be moving to get from one cog to the other. The chain doesn't move when you're coasting"
Customer: "So what are you saying? You can't fix it? I want a refund!"
BSM: . . . . (grrrrrrrrrr) . . .

Marketed along with Positron, Shimano's early attempt at indexed shifting, it seemed that the company was convinced that beginning cyclists were incapable of learning new skills - and the thing that kept so many American adults from riding bikes was basic incompetance.

By the way, the FF System utilized the "friction freewheel" on the rear hub as a safety measure. The rear freewheel was much stiffer than the front one, so the chain would continue to move when coasting - but the chain could still be stopped if something got caught in it, such as clothing, or a shoe, or someone's hand, etc.

FFS was made available on some models by Schwinn (the Suburban comes to mind, but there were others), and some department-store bicycles. The system was dropped in the early '80s because it was a bust - heavy, complicated, and ultimately unnecessary. And of course, repair/replacement parts were only available for a couple of years afterwards. I knew a guy who had a FFS-equipped Schwinn that totally seized up and I remember how dismayed he was when he was told it couldn't be fixed -- the only repair was to replace the entire crank, bottom bracket, and rear freewheel with "normal" parts.

Big surprise - but freewheeling cranks are BACK!

The French company HxR has just introduced a new product they call Easy Shift.


The Easy Shift crank is made for the latest 1x11 "Enduro" MTB drivetrains. Like the old Shimano FFS, it has a freewheeling mechanism built into the crank, but it is paired up with a true fixed-gear 11-speed rear hub. No "friction freewheel" here - so don't get anything caught in the chain, 'cause you'll lose it. Granted, that's the case with any fixed-gear drivetrain, but just sayin'.

Instead of being marketed for incompetent neophytes, the Easy Shift is claimed to be great for "technical" MTB conditions. But it's unclear just how much abuse the system can take. It's apparently necessary to pair the Easy Shift crank with a combination "bash guard" and "chain guide" -- to protect it from impacts below, and to keep the always-moving chain from derailing off the chainring.

I still question whether such a thing is necessary, but if anyone out there decides they can't live without it, being able to shift when coasting doesn't come cheap. The Easy Shift crank and bottom bracket alone are listed at about €450. Adding a chainring, the fixed-gear 11-speed hub, and the bash-guard/chain-guide takes the price up to €995. Based on current exchange rates, that's probably about $490 - $1090. Phew!

Don't be surprised if Shimano gets the last laugh by re-introducing their own FFS. I can see the ad tagline now:

See? We Told You So!

Wednesday, January 13, 2016

Data Glasses Again - A New Player In Town

Remember those Recon Jet goggles that are essentially a computer you wear on your face? The ones with microprocessor and sensor-loaded pods and battery packs that block peripheral vision, and a miniature monitor to take up about 1/3 of your forward vision?

Who needs to see where they're going when there's so much data to digest?  (Recon Jet)
Well, they're not the only game in town anymore. Lots of tech and performance junkies are now declaring the new Garmin Varia Vision as the "heads up display cyclists have been waiting for." By leaving out some of the microprocessing power and built-in sensors, Varia Vision instead syncs with a rider's other devices, such as their smartphone, their Garmin GPS-enabled ride computer and the new Garmin Varia rear-view radar system.

The Garmin Varia Vision is designed to attach to the user's own choice of riding glasses.
By "outsourcing" a lot of the sensors and power to the rider's other devices, Garmin's heads-up display is a bit more compact, uses smaller batteries, and offers longer run-time than the more self-contained Recon Jet glasses. The Garmin unit is also designed to be attached to the user's own choice of eyewear. All of these differences mean that the Garmin costs "only" $400 -- at least $100 less than the Recon wearable computer.

Garmin has a video to extol the virtues of Varia Vision display. In it, there are images that are supposed to give us an idea of what the rider would see with the device:

Dear God! I hope it doesn't actually look like this! Did we just get sucked into a video game? 

Are these Tron-like images supposed to make people want Varia Vision? Sorry, but it has the opposite effect on me.

Look familiar?
Check out the video here:



And it's not just for performance junkies, but Garmin also makes the claim that their "In-sight Display" is a great tool for commuters:

"I have this vision of keeping my focus forward," reads one quote from the video. "I have this vision of fewer close calls on my commute," reads another.

Want to keep your focus forward? Want fewer "close calls" on your commute? Then keep your focus on the road and your surroundings -- not on a computer display, whether mounted to your handlebars or right in front of your eyes. How important is it to get performance data on commute to work when you're sharing the road with over-caffeinated cell-phone-addled drivers? Do you need the In-sight display to tell you when you have an incoming call? Do you really need GPS directions to tell you how to get to work?

Even when all this info is being projected onto a tiny "heads-up" display on your glasses, just trying to process it mentally takes your focus off the road, and the possible dangers that can crop up in a split second. As far as I'm concerned, that's what leads to more close calls.

There is such a thing as data overload. When I'm riding -- especially in traffic -- the best computer I have available to me takes no batteries:

The rest is just a distraction.

Monday, January 11, 2016

New is Old Again: Expanding Chainring Cranks

You know what's wrong with front derailleurs? They're light, simple, and they work. Yes, it's true that if they're badly out of adjustment, you can drop the chain when shifting. But on the whole, they haven't changed much since the 1960s because they haven't really needed to.

People are always trying to find a better way, though, aren't they?

I saw a video for a new gear-changing innovation called Wavetrans Bicycle Transmission. "A new kind of bicycle transmission which uses a revolutionary logic," the website claims.

What is it, exactly? Wavetrans is essentially a crank with an expanding chainwheel. It has about 6 chainring "segments" which can expand or contract at the push of a button. Its inventor is trying to get backers for their concept, but you can see a working prototype on their website:


The company claims many "advatages" (sic) "compared to old gear shifter systems (Derailleur for example)." It can be shifted uphill, under load, the chain never comes off, and (my favorite) "no crunchy noises." Unless you're a dedicated granola-muncher. Then there's still lots of crunching.

Here you see the crank in its lowest gear. The prototype uses a pretty huge '80s-looking computer to control the unit and to shift gears. The FAQ page asks if users would be able to shift gears using their smartphone. "Yes, I'm sure there will be an option for that." Yes, I'm sure too.
Here, the chainring segments are expanded to the highest gear. 
You know what else is cool about Wavetrans? It's "something . . . that you have never seen before."




. . . Unless you actually know something about bicycle history, that is. In which case you know that these things go back almost to the beginning of the safety bicycle.

According to several sources, including Frank Berto's history The Dancing Chain, and Tony Hadland's Bicycle Design: An Illustrated History, there have been a number of expanding chain wheel systems, some dating back to the Victorian age -- most of them just variations on the same idea.

Here are a few:

1896 - Linley & Biggs Protean Gear. It used two half-chainwheels that could then be expanded by up to 4 teeth, though it took on an oval shape as it expanded.

1903 - Paradox expanding chainwheel. "Incorporated a complex mechanism to achieve a circular expandable chainwheel." (Hadland) It expanded in one-tooth increments up through 7 teeth.

1903 - Mitchell Any-Speed. "Rotated the chainwheel off-center. The eccentricity changed the effective diameter, giving infinitely variable gears." (Berto)

Searching on my own through some "expandable chainwheel" patents, I also found some of these diagrams:

One patent is for W.A. Leggo Jr. in 1894, and the other is for J.M. Cleland in 1898. I don't know if these ever made it onto the market.

None of the systems listed above lasted for more than a year or two. Development of such systems on the whole disappeared for a few decades as derailleurs and even internal hub gear systems proved to be simpler and reliable. But then, in the 1970s for some reason, they came back as more inventors once again looked to expanding chainwheels as the answer to a question nobody was asking.

Here are some of the more modern systems:

1974 - Hagen All-Speed Expanding Chainwheel. This had 6 smaller sprockets that moved outward as an inner spiral-plate turned. The gear range was 2.85 to 1, or 285%.
This Hagen All-Speed crank was up for sale on eBay last year. Top photo shows it in "low gear" position, and the bottom photo is "high gear." And it was infinitely variable in-between. At least one of the ads described it as having "a jillion speeds."

1983 - The Deal Drive had 16 speeds and a 2-to-1 range. It used 6 spring-loaded expanding segments. Pedal forces compressed the springs, retracting the chainwheel segments, thereby lowering the gear. An adjustment lever on the crank arm let users adjust the spring loading tension. Frank Berto described it as "well built and reliable. However it was heavy, expensive, and it had a limited gear range." Expired after 2 years.

A prototype of the Deal Drive. What must this thing have weighed? And how could anybody think that this was somehow preferable to a derailleur? (photo from Commutercycling)

1983 - Excel Cambiogear. Oddly enough, Excel was a division of Beatrice Foods, which tried to break into the bicycle business in the early 80s. The Cambiogear had 16 speeds, and a 3-to-1 range. Made of graphite-reinforced-plastic. It lasted 1 year.

The Excel Cambiogear, front, and backside. Made of graphite-reinforced plastic, it had small chainring "segments" that expanded or contracted on these spiral-like grooves, not terribly different from the Hagen All-Speed.
Here you can see one of the chainring segments.

The photos above are screenshots from an explanatory video of the Excel Cambiogear I found on YouTube. You can watch it here:


Clearly, this idea has been tried (and abandoned) numerous times in over a century. And the Wavetrans isn't even the only expanding chainwheel crank startup today. Another startup - the VECTr Variably Expanding Chain Tranmission - apparently applied for a patent last fall on their own version of this old idea.

Here's a prototype of the VECTr, which uses a heavily modified Deore crank. It looks like the little toothed chainring segments have 5 distinct positions, giving the user 5 gear selections ranging from 24 to 44 tooth equivalent.
So, about the only thing I can see that sets the Wavetrans apart from all these other systems is that it's electronically operated. Push-button electronic shifting chainrings, without a derailleur. Well, that's something we've never seen before.

Oh, wait. . .
Scan from a 1987 issue of Cyclist. The Browning Automatic Transmission used hinged (not expanding) chainrings, and an electronic control box to change gears. Early tests by a lot of the bike magazines of the time declared it an unqualified success. It was later put into full mass production by SunTour (called "The Beast") and suffered from reliability problems. Many were recalled. Then SunTour went out of business. Browning tried to keep the design going for a few years on their own, but never found a market for a shifting system that cost about twice as much as a Shimano derailleur-based drivetrain.

Something tells me that people today are no more likely to adopt a transmission that's heavier, more expensive, and more complicated than a derailleur system than they were 20, 30 or even 100 years ago. I just don't see the Wavetrans (or the VECTr, or any other similar ideas that might be brewing out there today) having any more success than their Victorian-era counterparts, or any of the revivals from the '70s and '80s.

Friday, January 8, 2016

Do Cyclists Make Better Drivers?

In the 1954 safety education film, Drive Your Bike, a group of adolescent boys learn from their coach about how thinking like a driver would help them be better, safer bicyclists -- and how being better bicyclists would help them become better drivers when the time came. The movie's car-centric message was fairly typical of bike safety films from the era -- implying that bicycles are for kids, while adults drive cars (at least the "normal" ones did).

"Always use your head and think about safety," says the coach. "By starting now and learning to drive your bikes, you'll be able to drive an automobile when you're old enough. And you'll be able to do a good safe job of it."
I've poked fun at the stiff monotone delivery of that movie's lessons, and while it's doubtful that the filmmakers in the '50s ever expected that anyone would continue to ride a bike after they'd get their drivers' license, there's definitely something to the idea that being a good bicyclist makes someone a better driver. I'll bet most people reading this would agree. And now an insurance company has come around to the same conclusion.

On the website for Carinsurance4cyclists.com, which appears to be U.K.-based, the insurance firm cites a number of reasons why bicyclists earn lower rates. "Your on-road cycling experience has made you more alert and road aware than the average car driver and that deserves special attention," says the company.

from carinsurance4cyclists.
"Improved Spatial Awareness. In town or in the countryside you'll be more aware of how you fit into your surroundings and ride or drive accordingly."

"Road Alert. Your experience on your bike means you're more alert to the dangers of road use and better able to anticipate hazards."

"Healthy Lifestyle. Physical fitness means you value your body. It also suggests improved mental agility and that makes you a more responsive driver."

As a lifetime bicyclist, as well as an occasional motorcyclist, I absolutely agree with that. I really believe that either type of cyclist learns to be more observant of their surroundings -- looking farther ahead, being more aware of blind spots, and spotting (and reacting to) dangers earlier. A cyclist develops senses that car-centric drivers never know about.

Here's an example. I was in my car, driving on a wide highway towards one of the major shopping-and-dining areas in our locale. There were two traffic lanes in both directions, separated by a turn lane in the middle. I was in the left lane, with another car just to my right-side rear quarter, and we were approaching an intersection with a traffic light which was green. Approaching the intersection from the opposite direction was a car with a young woman driving, and she had just moved into the turn lane to make a left turn.

It sounds weird to say it, because cars don't have "body language" exactly, but something about the approaching car told me that the driver was going to make the left turn despite the fact that two cars were coming right for her going about 45 mph. I was close enough to the oncoming left-turning car that I could literally see the driver through her windshield. I could see her face, and I could see her eyes looking ahead -- but something told me that even though she appeared to be looking right at us, it was as if she didn't see us coming.

All of this was happening in a fraction of a second, yet it was almost like time and everything slowed down around me. I instinctively started moving my foot from the accelerator to the brake, and sure enough, at that moment, she started turning just as I'd predicted. I was already reacting, slowing hard enough to feel my anti-lock brakes pulse, while I was making a quick evasive "S-maneuver" around her car and then back into my lane. The driver to my right, caught completely off-guard, slammed into her with full force, sending her car into a 360-degree spin that I could see happening in my peripheral vision. A third car was also involved in the pileup. After I pulled off the road in a safe spot, I found myself running back to the scene to check on everyone involved while phoning 911. Paramedics took one driver away, but luckily nobody sustained life-changing injuries.

Of everyone involved in the incident, being out in front I had the least time to react, yet I was the one who was able to avoid the crash.

Yes, this is totally anecdotal and hardly objective "proof," but I have no doubt that the fact that I was able to predict and react the way I did was helped by my experiences as a cyclist -- who is typically a more vulnerable road user. And I'd be willing to bet that many people reading this have similar stories to share.

On a related note, RoadCC also ran a story recently on this car insurance discount. I read in the comments section something that just has to be the greatest blog comment and expression of British slang that I've ever read:
"Certainly I drive less like a monumental cockwomble since starting to cycle regularly."

Oh my god, I love that. It sums it all up so perfectly.

Not everybody out there would agree that we cyclists drive better. The RoadCC article also cites a trucking company director who claims that "lorry drivers (that's 'trucks' to us yanks) are the best users of the road while cyclists are the worst." Of course we'd probably all disagree loudly, but I'd love to see some objective studies on the idea that cyclists really do drive better, as such studies might lead to more insurance companies recognizing us with better rates.

By the way - how does carinsurance4cyclists determine that a person really is a cyclist, and not just someone checking a box to get a discount? Apparently it is necessary to be a member of one of the U.K.'s cycling clubs. I suppose that works. I recall that I used to get a break on my motorcycle insurance for belonging to the American Motorcycle Association (AMA) and for having completed a sanctioned motorcycle-riding course.

It would be great if more insurance companies, like some of those here in the U.S., followed that lead.

How about it, Flo?
In the meantime, I can't stop thinking of a phrase that needs to become a part of eveyone's lexicon, and would even make a great t-shirt or bumper sticker:

Don't be a MONUMENTAL COCKWOMBLE. Ride a bike.

Wednesday, January 6, 2016

Old Is Good: Specialized Triple Cranks

In the mid 1970s, Mike Sinyard started Specialized Bicycle Imports, which (as the name implied) was an importer of bicycles and components - particularly from Italy at first, then later from Japan. The name was later shortened to simply Specialized, and as anybody reading this already knows, they are now one of the giants of the industry. From a retrogrouchy perspective, there isn't much among the company's current offerings to get very excited about. But in the early and mid '80s, they offered a line of really nice Japanese-built bikes, and a nearly full range of components designed by the company and manufactured to very high quality standards in Japan. Stems and handlebars from Nitto. Hubs from Sunshine/Sansin. Cranks from Sugino. Pedals from MKS. Bottom brackets and headsets from Tange. And don't forget the tires, which were among the first really good clinchers available for high-performance bikes. About the only thing they didn't offer was derailleurs. In most cases, the components were more than just re-labeled pieces from their respective manufacturers, but were unique designs made to very high specifications.

Just as a little point about how nice the bicycles were, who among Retrogrouch Blog readers wouldn't start salivating like one of Pavlov's dogs over a mid-'80s mint condition red Specialized Allez SE with SunTour Superbe components, just like the bikes from the 1985 film American Flyers? . . . Exactly. Also, I have one of the early Stumpjumpers with the lugged frame and twin-plate fork crown, and the workmanship on that frame is fantastic.

Anyhow, as I'm gathering up components for a bike build, I thought I'd take a close look at one of my favorite triple cranksets - the Specialized ST, sometimes known as the "flag" crank because of the logo engraved on the arms. It's a really well-designed crank - simple, pretty, and strong. I've used them on a few bike builds over the years, whether built for myself or for others.

It's the kind of design that looks good on a bike whether new or old.

I was able to get some info about the cranks from Jim Merz, who had been one of the pioneering framebuilders in the Portland, Oregon bike scene until he went to work for Specialized as a product designer in 1982. He has also been a "Master Frame Builder" for the company. Jim was the designer of these cranks, and many other high-quality components. According to Jim, the cranks were cold forged, using the strongest alloys available, and with rings made from 7075 T6 aluminum - the same as was used by Campagnolo. As mentioned, the cranks were manufactured for Specialized by Sugino.

One thing about the crank is that, when it was created in the early '80s, it was on the leading curve of a design trend that would come to define the decade. Notice the smooth "aero" look, the deeply beveled arms, and the low-profile junction where the arm meets the spider -- as opposed to the steep-shouldered, more "squared off" look of many earlier cranks. It also used a fairly short BB spindle compared to most triple cranks. It was not only nice-looking, but was also very strong. The design was such as to help minimize possible built-in stress risers that could lead to cracking over time.

As a contrast, the sharp transition between the arm and the spider on this old Campagnolo crank serves as a stress riser, where cracks could develop. Lots of old Campy cranks suffer this fate. With continued use, a crack like this could eventually break all the way through. (photo, minus added text, from fixed.org.au forum)

The style of the crank would become very familiar through the decade as many other cranks would have a similar design in the '80s. SunTour cranks (also made by Sugino), Shimano, Sakae, and others would adopt the smooth, low-profile look. In fact, some of Sugino's current model cranks, such as the Alpina (shown left) still have the same basic style, even 30 years later.

Another detail about the crank that makes it very versatile is its 110/74 bolt circle diameter (BCD). Though that would quickly become the most common standard for triple cranks for the next couple of decades, it was still a pretty fresh development when this crank was designed.

The crank used the 110/74 BCD which means that chainrings are easy to find, even today.
About that 110/74 BCD Standard:

In the 1970s, as long-distance touring bikes gained popularity (especially after the epic Bikecentennial ride of 1976), and then at the end of the decade when mountain bikes were in their infancy, finding a good wide-range triple crank with seriously low gearing wasn't so easy. There were numerous "standards" for bolt circle diameter, and very little compatibility between different brands. One of the more popular choices for tourists and early mountain bikers was the TA Cyclotourist -- not necessarily because they loved the crank so much (it had some idiosyncrasies) but because it could be had with a then-diminutive 26 tooth granny ring. The TA had a tiny 50.4 mm BCD onto which the biggest chainring bolted. Then the middle and inner rings bolted directly onto the outer ring with an 80 mm bolt circle. One downside of the crank was that the space between the rings and the crank arm was so narrow that it could create interference with some front derailleurs. And the whole thing bolted together with a confusing mess of different sized nuts and bolts. Also, larger chainrings on the TA crank could lack stiffness. The bigger the ring, the more it could flex. Still, for many people, and for quite a while, it was the best thing going.

Stronglight had certain models that were very similar to (or interchangeable with) the TA Cyclotourist, but they also had other, more modern triple cranks (their model 99 comes to mind, for example) that used a proprietary 86 mm BCD. Those were also copied by Sakae Ringyo (SR) and used on some of Trek's early touring bikes. They were decent triple cranks, but the smallest chainring one could install was 28 teeth. Low, but not low enough for some tourists and mountain bikers.

When Shimano released its original Deore group in 1981, which was intended to be a premium group for touring bikes, the first generation Deore crank copied the 50.4 BCD used by TA. But in typical Shimano fashion (does not play well with others), only the outer ring was interchangeable with the TA Cyclotourist. The middle and inner rings used a proprietary 85 BCD, making them compatible with nothing else. It also meant that the lowest gear was limited to 28 teeth.

In 1982, Sugino released the AT triple crank. "AT" stood for "Aero Tour" but it probably wasn't a coincidence that it was just like "TA" backwards. The AT had the outer and middle rings bolted to a 110 mm circle, which could accept rings as small as 34 teeth (They also offered rings as large as 53 teeth, but nowadays it's hard to find them larger than 50). A second set of threaded holes was set into the spider with a 74 mm bolt circle, which could accept a granny ring as small as 24 teeth. Altogether it was a good combination. The larger rings still got plenty of support, avoiding the flex that would come with a smaller bolt circle. Middle rings could be as small as 34, and the 24 tooth granny ring was about the lowest gear anybody was offering at the time. I remember a number of bikes in the '80s, especially sport-touring models, that came with 110/74 cranks that were set up as doubles. Turning them into triples if the owner wished was a simple operation. The cult-bike Bridgestone XO-1 came equipped like that, too.

As Jim Merz tells me, he designed the Specialized crank in 1983, using the same 110/74 BCD. Sakae got a version on the market very quickly. When Shimano redesigned their Deore crank, around '84, they made a rare choice to adopt 110/74 as well. Pretty soon many in the industry were embracing a common standard for triple cranks. Even TA started making cranks and rings to the standard. And there was much rejoicing.

As usual, the idea of common standards has gone out the window, and cranks today are all over the place. Innovations such as MicroDrive in the '90s made bolt circles and chainrings even smaller (more ground clearance for mountain bikes, I guess), and now more and more cranks have discontinued 5-bolt spiders in favor of 4-bolt versions - many with their own unique asymmetrical bolt patterns, and others with removable spiders. But luckily 110/74 rings were once very common and can still be found today without trouble.

The ST-4:

The ST triple crank had a less expensive sibling, designated as the ST-4. Overall, the cranks looked very similar, with the most obvious difference being the logo. However, the real difference between the two was not in the logo, but in the manufacturing. The ST crank was cold-forged out of the strongest available aluminum alloy, whereas the ST-4 was made by the process known as gravity casting -- sometimes mistakenly called "melt forging" but there is a difference. Read on . . .

That's the cold-forged ST on the left, and its similar-looking sibling (minus rings) on the right. The model designations are marked on the back, but the logo ("flag" vs. "S") is a quick identifier.

Cold Forging vs. Hot Forging vs. Gravity Casting vs. Melt Forging

They're all fine ways to make a bicycle crank, but differences in methods and materials affect the strength - and differences in the manufacturing cost obviously affect the price. A really good description of all the methods can be found in the 1992 Bridgestone catalog, but here's a quick summary:

Cold forging starts with the strongest alloys, and requires several major wallops (not a technical term) with hardened forging dies with tons of weight and pressure -- as in, hundreds of tons. Cold forging imparts a grain structure that makes the component very strong, but the tooling and equipment mean more expense. Very few bicycle component makers can afford the massive forging "hammers," and therefore most actually have their cold forging outsourced to specialists. Because of the added strength, cold forged components, like cranks, can be made sleeker and lighter. By the way, Jan Heine's blog had an interesting article last year about forging hammers and the companies that do such work (HERE).

Hot forging involves alloys that are slightly lower in strength than cold forging (though still very strong), heating them to make them softer, then giving them typically one or two hard wallops in the forging dies. It still imparts a grain structure to the component so the parts are very strong, but it takes fewer wallops and less tooling so the cost is lower.

Gravity casting and melt forging both involve melting alloys that start out as somewhat lower strength from either of the previously described methods - but between the two, gravity casting uses a stronger alloy than melt forging. In gravity casting, the molten metal is poured into a mold, then allowed to cool slowly while any air bubbles that might be present gravitate upward and out. In melt forging, the molten metal is forced into a mold under pressure, then liquid-cooled quickly. It is the fastest method and probably requires the least expensive tooling, though the material is not necessarily as strong, nor do the parts develop the same kind of grain structure. For that reason, melt-forged components tend to be "chunkier" to make up for it. Melt forged components also don't take to anodizing, so the finished products are often painted or powder coated. It goes without saying that melt forging is the least expensive of the described methods.

By the way, the '92 Bridgestone catalog says that the Specialized ST-4 crank was gravity cast, but then got extra strength by being whacked in a forging die for good measure. How cool is that?

Cranks in the Vintage Market:

If you're looking at either of these Specialized cranks on the vintage marketplace, like eBay, keep in mind that the prices will vary more by condition than by the model of crank. Most buyers and sellers on eBay or elsewhere probably don't really know the difference between the two versions, nor do they know or care what the things sold for when new. A really clean ST-4  will probably sell for more than a badly scuffed ST, regardless of what the original prices might have been. It's good to know what you're getting, though. Sometimes I see these selling for $100 or more, but unless it's unused, mint-in-the-box, I'd say that's ridiculous. Clean used examples like the ones shown above can often be found for under $50.

Monday, January 4, 2016

Old Is Good: Shimano Deore MT60

As I'm picking out components for an upcoming project (there will be more on the project later - patience, please) I pulled out this near-mint condition Deore rear derailleur (RD-MT60, in Shimano-ese) from either '87 or '88. It was taken off another project bike some years ago and put into a box to wait for the right bike to come along.
Probably the best mountain bike derailleur of its time, but
looks perfectly at home on road bikes, too.

I've always been a SunTour guy, but this Deore MT60 represents a pretty great "modern" derailleur, made at just the time when Shimano was thoroughly establishing their dominance of the bicycle component market. It was nicely styled, without a lot of the typical Shimano gimmickry, and built to last under harsh conditions. Though made primarily for mountain bikes, its simple all-silver finish looked good on road bikes too.

The 1987 Deore MT60 was one of the first indexing mountain bike derailleurs (SunTour released their indexing Accushift line for both road and MTBs that same year), on the heels of Shimano's successful indexing road derailleurs, the Dura Ace 7400 and 600EX SIS of 1985 and '86 respectively. Deore had first been introduced in 1981 as a high-end touring group, but its real impact was in the burgeoning mountain bike market. The MT60  was the first in the Deore line to incorporate the slant-parallelogram design first patented by SunTour, then adopted by Shimano after SunTour's patent expired. It also used the spring-loaded upper pivot that Shimano had already been known for, which contributed to quick, crisp shifting. This derailleur brought the performance of Dura Ace to mountain/touring bikes, in a sturdier package with more seals, etc.

One of the great things about this derailleur is that it will shift crisply and smoothly over a wide range - at least as well as the great old SunTour GT models. But being made for mountain bike duties, it should also prove very durable. Ironically, for a long time, it was SunTour that had simple, functional derailleur designs, and Shimano that seemed to go for gimmicks and "innovations" that were like answers to questions nobody asked. But after SunTour had a string of early '80s mis-steps, like the self-destructing Mountech, or other overly complex "Tech"-series derailleurs, such as the Superbe Tech, or the weird 3-pulley LeTech, suddenly it was Shimano that seemed like the solid, stable choice. This Deore just epitomized that.

So, do I care that this derailleur can index-shift? Not a bit - but in general, a derailleur that works well with indexing levers will also shift beautifully with friction levers. I plan to use it with some old SunTour ratcheting bar-end shifters.

Compared with what would come later, this old Deore is a classic-looking piece of equipment. And while it was only designed for 6-speed gearing (it would probably work fine on 7 or even 8-speeds - not that it matters) its performance should be as good as anything made currently.

Just for laughs, let's take a look at what the Deore looks like today:

The current-generation Deore looks like it was designed by a Japanese Animé cartoonist. Can anyone imagine bolting this thing onto a road bike today?
Obviously, the components for road and mountain bikes have diverged considerably since 1988. If someone wants a current model wide-range derailleur that won't look out of place on an older road bike, what do they do?

Amidst a line full of monstrous-looking mountain bike derailleurs, and black-painted road units, the closest thing in Shimano's current line to that MT60 Deore is probably this low-end 8-speed Claris. Except for its painted finish (at least it's silver), and somewhat "swoopier" lines, it seems to share quite a bit with my old Deore. I wouldn't be surprised if most of the geometry and other dimensions were pretty much the same.